Concrete vs Composite Deck vs Wood Cost – How Do Long-Term Expenses Compare

Table of Contents 

When creating the perfect outdoor space with a deck that will last through time, finding the ideal material for your budget, needs, and expectations is crucial. There are several options for you to choose from, each with advantages and disadvantages. Some materials are more expensive, but they will last a lot longer. Here’s a complete overview of deck material prices and longevity. 

What’s the Best Material for a Deck? 

When planning to build a deck, you’ll have three main choices of material: concrete, composite or wood. 

• Concrete: With concrete, you’ll get a patio rather than a deck per se. It is suitable for a flat area, so if your land is sloped, a deck might be a better option. Concrete is very durable and is low maintenance. There are ways to have it textured, stained or stamped to create an appealing look. When well maintained, a concrete patio can last for decades. However, be mindful of the location, as concrete will absorb and retain heat, making the patio potentially uncomfortable during summer unless you can create shade. 

  Concrete patios can be quite expensive to build. On the other hand, maintenance is usually minimal, and you might not need a permit to build one. However, it won’t add the same value to your home as a deck. 

• Composite: Composite is made of recycled wood fibres and plastic. Depending on the manufacturer, composite can be an eco-friendly option. Thanks to its composition, it resists rot, insect damage and decay better than wood. This means that over time, you won’t need to invest time and money in maintaining a composite deck, as you might with a wood deck. You will still need to wipe it down or sweep it when needed. They often come with a warranty. 

  Composite is, however, more costly than wood. It can cost between 30% to 35% more than wood, and the installation can come with a higher price tag. Its durability has a price, but depending on the material and environmental factors, a composite deck can last 25 years or longer. This means that over time, a composite deck can end up being less expensive than a wood one. 

• Wood: People choose wood decking mainly for two reasons: its lower cost and its aesthetically pleasing appearance. Installation can be simple, and the material offers a lot of flexibility for designs. It’s also a very comfortable material that won’t become too hot in the summer or too cold in between seasons.

  Wood is durable but will still need some maintenance, including sanding and resealing or painting, which can add a significant cost down the line. Wood deck maintenance costs range between $1 and $5 per square foot. This maintenance must be done every two years at most to maintain a beautiful finish. This type of deck generally lasts between 10 and 15 years, but can last longer in some cases. 

Is Cedar Decking Worth the Money? 

There’s a reason cedar was used for wardrobes and chests back in the day. This wood is naturally resistant to bugs, rot, and decay, making it perfect for decking. A cedar deck can last up to 20 years when well maintained.  

With cedar deck board prices that vary from $2 and more per linear foot, the material is well worth the money. It’s not as high maintenance as other types of wood and is an eco-friendly option as it doesn’t require harsh chemical treatment. When it comes to cedar vs composite decking cost, cedar is usually lower priced. However, the prices cross over, meaning that a high-end cedar can be the same price or even more expensive than some lower-quality composite. 

Its pleasing look can also increase the value of your house. 

Is Composite Decking Worth the Money? 

Composite decks are known to be expensive, but their durability and the low amount of effort and money needed for maintenance are hard to beat. Is composite decking worth it? Generally speaking, yes. Reputable manufacturers offer a generous warranty, sometimes up to 25 years, some even up to 50 years, making this a hassle-free option. While low-end composites may not have the same appeal as natural wood, high-end brands imitate it beautifully and offer rich textures. No matter which composite you choose, there is a wide selection of colours available across all ranges and price points. A good quality composite deck will also add value to your home. 

Which Deck Material Offers the Best Value for the Money? 

This is a tough question, as each material has pros and cons. Composite is expensive but will last the longest. Concrete is expensive and low maintenance but lacks the appeal of wood or even composite. Wood is a noble and beautiful material and is budget-friendly in terms of initial costs. However, the maintenance cost is the highest of the three options. 

For installation, the price range is extensive for both a patio and a deck. The labour cost to build a deck per square foot will vary greatly depending on the model built and the materials used. It is always best to check with professionals to get an exact estimate. 

Here is a table to give you a general idea of the material and labor costs you can expect for a deck or patio, depending on the chosen material. These costs are approximate and can vary significantly based on the complexity of the design and the contractor’s hourly rate. They also only include the platform of the deck and do not include railings or stairs. For an accurate estimate, it is always best to consult professionals. 

It’s also important to understand that for all these materials, the quality will make a huge difference. For example, in terms of composite deck vs wood cost, a poorly made composite can be less expensive, but it might not last as long as promised. On the other hand, high-quality wood can be more expensive. 

The price and longevity of decking materials are key points to consider when making a choice. However, other factors need to be considered, such as the slope of your land, the climate, and the sun exposure. The most economical option in ideal conditions might not work for your house for a variety of reasons. This is why working with a trusted expert is the key to finding the perfect solution. Do not hesitate to contact us, our team will be happy to evaluate which deck would best suit your needs.